The Why Behind the What: Why Most People Struggle Because They’re Missing Half the Equation
Picture this: You’re in the locker room after a great Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu class, and a fellow white belt is raving about how awesome the instructor was at explaining the techniques.
“He breaks everything down so clearly,” he says. “I can actually understand what to do and how to do it.”
You agree—the instructor is indeed excellent at teaching techniques.
But then you mention something that makes your training partner pause:
“One of my favorite instructors is actually the black belt who shows up on open mat Sundays. He’s great at explaining the underlying principles and philosophy of BJJ.”
That conversation crystallized something I’ve observed across decades of martial arts, construction work, business building, and life in general: most people focus obsessively on the what and how while completely neglecting the why—and this is precisely why they struggle.
They want to be taught what to do and how to do something.
After all, it’s practical. You can see immediate results.
It feels like you’re making progress.
Until suddenly, you’re not.
Understanding the why is just as important—if not more important—for creating lasting progress and success.
Because any one technique will work in a few situations but not all, while the underlying principles are the universal rules that apply to the vast majority of situations.
Start With Why
I remember when Simon Sinek first got on my radar when he was promoting his book, Start With Why, because this was the question I had been asking my whole life.
In fact, I was so bothersome to my mother endlessly asking curious question about “why” that she bought me a series of books of “Tell Me Why…” I loved them!
The Technique Collector Trap
But I was surprised that most people don’t care about why, they’re more interested in what and how.
I’ve watched this pattern play out countless times in martial arts.
Students become “technique collectors”—accumulating hundreds of moves, counters, and variations without understanding the fundamental principles that make them work, studying all, mastering none.
They’re like someone trying to learn a language by memorizing individual sentences without understanding grammar, syntax, or the logic that connects words into meaning.
When their memorized techniques don’t work in live situations, they don’t know why.
They can’t adapt.
They can’t troubleshoot.
They end up throwing spaghetti at the wall to see what sticks, cycling through their mental library of techniques hoping something will work.
This approach creates several problems:
Overwhelm: With hundreds of techniques to choose from, decision-making becomes paralyzed.
Inefficiency: Time and energy are wasted on techniques that don’t fit the situation.
Fragility: When techniques fail, there’s no deeper understanding to fall back on.
Plateauing: Progress stalls because there’s no foundation for continued growth.
Frustration: The gap between knowledge and application becomes a source of constant stress.
The Principle-Based Approach
Contrast this with students who understand principles.
They might know fewer techniques, but they understand why each technique works, when it applies, and how to modify it when conditions change.
In BJJ, for example, understanding principles like:
- Leverage: Using mechanical advantage to overcome strength differences
- Base and posture: Maintaining stability while disrupting your opponent’s
- Timing: Recognizing when your opponent is vulnerable
- Distance management: Controlling the space between you and your opponent
- Energy conservation: Using minimal effort for maximum effect
These principles apply to thousands of situations and can generate countless techniques organically.
The principle-based student doesn’t need to memorize every possible variation of a submission.
They understand the underlying mechanics of joint manipulation and can adapt in real-time based on how their opponent responds.
The Construction Site Lesson
This same pattern played out during my decades in construction.
I worked with two types of people:
Technique collectors: Workers who knew how to perform specific tasks exactly as they were taught.
They could frame a wall, pour concrete, or install electrical systems as long as conditions matched their training.
But when something unexpected happened—and something always happens on construction sites—they were lost.
Principle understanders: Workers who grasped the underlying physics, engineering, and logic behind construction methods.
They understood why buildings are built the way they are, what forces need to be managed, and how different materials behave under various conditions.
When problems arose, the technique collectors would freeze or panic.
The principle understanders would analyze the situation, understand what was happening, and devise solutions.
Guess which group became foremen, supervisors, and eventually business owners?
The Business Building Application
The same dynamic exists in entrepreneurship and business building.
Many people focus obsessively on tactics—specific marketing techniques, particular software tools, exact scripts and formulas—without understanding the underlying principles of human psychology, market dynamics, and value creation.
They follow step-by-step guides and detailed blueprints, expecting identical results.
When the tactics don’t work in their specific situation, they assume they need different tactics.
They become course junkies, constantly searching for the “right” technique instead of developing deeper understanding.
Successful entrepreneurs understand principles like:
- Value creation: Solving real problems for real people
- Market validation: Testing assumptions before major investments
- Customer psychology: Understanding what motivates purchasing decisions
- Systems thinking: Building processes that can scale and improve
- Risk management: Balancing potential rewards with potential losses
These principles allow them to navigate changing markets, adapt to new technologies, and create solutions for problems that don’t have existing playbooks.
The Life Application
This what-versus-why dynamic affects every area of life:
Relationships: Memorizing communication techniques versus understanding empathy, respect, and genuine care for others.
Health: Following specific diet and exercise programs versus understanding nutrition science, movement principles, and your body’s individual needs.
Finance: Using particular investment strategies versus understanding compound interest, risk assessment, and economic principles.
Parenting: Applying specific discipline techniques versus understanding child development, individual personality differences, and the long-term goals of raising healthy adults.
Career development: Learning specific job skills versus understanding value creation, market trends, and human networking principles.
In every case, the principle-based approach creates more adaptability, resilience, and long-term success.
Why People Avoid the Why
If understanding principles is so powerful, why do most people focus only on techniques?
Several factors contribute to this preference:
Immediate Gratification
Techniques provide instant results and visible progress. Principles take longer to understand and apply.
Concrete vs. Abstract
Techniques are tangible and specific. Principles are conceptual and require more mental effort to grasp.
Fear of Complexity
Understanding principles requires acknowledging that situations are more complex than simple formulas can address.
Educational System Conditioning
Most educational systems emphasize memorization and step-by-step procedures over critical thinking and principle understanding.
Marketing Influence
Courses, books, and programs sell better when they promise specific techniques rather than deep understanding.
Ego Protection
It’s easier to blame a technique for not working than to admit you don’t understand the underlying principles.
But here’s the trap: the short-term ease of technique focus creates long-term struggle and limitation.
The Balance Point
The solution isn’t to abandon techniques entirely and focus only on principles.
It’s about finding the right balance between the pragmatic and the theoretical, the what and the why.
Too much technique focus without principle understanding leads to:
- Rigid thinking and inability to adapt
- Overwhelming complexity as you accumulate more techniques
- Frustration when techniques don’t work in new situations
- Dependence on external instruction for every new challenge
Too much principle focus without practical application leads to:
- Analysis paralysis and overthinking
- Inability to take concrete action
- Theoretical knowledge that doesn’t translate to real-world results
- Becoming an armchair philosopher rather than a practitioner
The optimal approach combines both:
- Learn techniques as practical applications of underlying principles
- Understand principles through experimentation with various techniques
- Use techniques as laboratories for testing and refining principle understanding
- Apply principles to generate new techniques when existing ones don’t fit
The Teaching Two-Step
The best instructors I’ve encountered across martial arts, construction, and business all follow a similar pattern:
Step 1: Teach the Technique
Show exactly what to do and how to do it. Break it down into clear, actionable steps. Provide immediate feedback and correction.
Step 2: Explain the Principles
Discuss why the technique works, what principles it demonstrates, how it connects to other techniques, and when it might not be the best choice.
This two-step approach gives students both immediate practical tools and the deeper understanding needed for long-term growth.
How to Develop Principle Understanding
If you recognize that you’ve been focusing too heavily on techniques without understanding principles, here’s how to develop deeper comprehension:
Ask Better Questions
Instead of just “How do I do this?” also ask:
- “Why does this work?”
- “When would this not work?”
- “What principle is this demonstrating?”
- “How does this connect to other things I know?”
- “What would happen if I modified this approach?”
Study Fundamentals
Whatever field you’re in, go back and study the foundational principles:
- In martial arts: physics, anatomy, psychology
- n business: economics, psychology, systems thinking
- In relationships: human psychology, communication theory
- In health: physiology, nutrition science, stress management
Experiment and Analyze
Don’t just practice techniques—experiment with variations and analyze what happens:
- What changes when you modify the technique?
- Which elements are essential and which are optional?
- How do different opponents/situations affect the technique?
Teach Others
Teaching forces you to understand principles deeply enough to explain them. You can’t just demonstrate—you have to articulate the why.
Cross-Train
Study related fields to see how similar principles apply in different contexts. This deepens your understanding and reveals universal patterns.
Find Principle-Focused Mentors
Seek out instructors, mentors, and resources that emphasize understanding over just technique accumulation.
The Long-Term Payoff
Developing principle understanding requires more effort upfront, but the long-term payoff is enormous:
Adaptability: You can handle new situations that don’t match your previous experience.
Efficiency: You choose the right approach more quickly instead of trial-and-error.
Innovation: You can create new solutions instead of just copying existing ones.
Teaching Ability: You can help others understand, not just demonstrate.
Confidence: You trust your ability to figure things out instead of feeling dependent on external instruction.
Mastery: You develop true expertise instead of just technical proficiency.
Your Why-Finding Action Plan
Starting today, begin implementing these strategies:
Week 1: Assessment
- Identify areas where you’ve been technique-focused without principle understanding
- List three techniques you use regularly but don’t fully understand why they work
- Find one principle-focused resource (book, instructor, course) in your main area of interest
Week 2: Investigation
- For each technique you identified, research the underlying principles
- Start asking “why” questions in your practice or work
- Experiment with modifying familiar techniques to test your understanding
Week 3: Application
- Practice explaining techniques to others, focusing on the principles
- Look for connections between different techniques that share common principles
- Begin developing your own variations based on principle understanding
Week 4: Integration
- Make principle investigation a regular part of your learning process
- Seek out instruction that emphasizes understanding over just technique acquisition
- Begin teaching or mentoring others to deepen your own understanding
The Bottom Line
Most people struggle in life because they focus obsessively on what to do and how to do it while completely neglecting why it works.
They become technique collectors instead of principle understanders, and this approach inevitably leads to plateaus, frustration, and inability to adapt to new situations.
The solution isn’t to abandon practical techniques—it’s to balance the pragmatic with the theoretical, the what with the why.
When you understand both the surface technique and the underlying principles, you develop the adaptability, creativity, and confidence that characterize true mastery.
Whether it’s that black belt explaining the philosophy behind BJJ techniques, the experienced foreman who understands construction principles, or the successful entrepreneur who grasps market dynamics, the people who excel over the long term are those who invest in understanding why things work, not just how they work.
Your techniques will serve you in specific situations.
Your principles will serve you for a lifetime.
The choice is yours: you can continue collecting techniques and hoping they’ll work when you need them, or you can invest in understanding the deeper principles that will allow you to adapt, create, and excel regardless of what challenges you face.
Stop throwing spaghetti at the wall. Start understanding why some spaghetti sticks and others don’t.
Your future self—more adaptable, more confident, and more capable—will thank you for making the effort to understand not just what to do, but why it works.